It's January 1, 2011 and that can mean only one thing: the Cybils shortlists have been announced!
In my cursory review of the shortlists I've come across a few books that I've actually read (mostly nonfiction), a couple books we all kinda knew would make the list (
Reckless
,
The Dark Game
,
Ship Breaker
), a slew of books that are on my TBR pile (
Milo: Sticky Notes and Brain Freeze
,
Scrawl
,
Plain Kate
, etc.) and then an unendingly long list of books that I either didn't really know about, or knew about, but just hadn't considered (
Harmonic Feedback
,
Belly Up
,
Ninth Ward
). Guess I've got a lot of reading to do.
I was most surprised about the books that I feel everyone is talking about in the blogosphere, (mostly for Newbery and Printz consideration) but didn't make the list. To my mind, the Newbery-ish titles would include Rita Williams-Garcia's
One Crazy Summer
, Deborah Wiles'
Countdown
, and Katherine Erskine's
Mockingbird
. And for Printz-ly titles (which I now feel a bit out of touch with because my work with middle schoolers has redirected my reading priorities) I'd have thought Jennifer Donnelly's
Revolution
, Melina Marchetta's
Finnikin of the Rock
, and/or Catherine Fisher's
Incarceron
would have seen some love. It seems like the Cybils lists are generally lacking in historical fiction, which isn't a bad thing per se, but perhaps it might indicate that a separate historical fiction category should be added to showcase the genre. But who am I to advise on such matters?
Alas, Happy New Year!
The LibrariYAn is an Amazon Associate. If you click from links on this blog to Amazon and buy something (anything!), I receive a small percentage of the purchase price.
It's always the surprises that make the Cybils fun. However, it's not accurate to say that Incarceron didn't get any love from the Cybils; it was a finalist in 2007 from the UK edition, so we loved it before a lot of people had even heard of it! It wasn't eligible to be reconsidered this year since it was already a Cybils book in a previous year.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the clarification - and good to hear! It's a favorite with my students.
ReplyDelete